Broken Promises: The Legacy of Joe Biden

On November 17th, 2026, former president Joseph Biden released his memoir, Promise Me, America. At every turn, the man who led the Atlantic alliance as president for four years repeatedly proves himself as unable to defend it without attempting to apologize for it. Consistently, throughout his writing, Biden defends his legacy not by its own merits, but as a series of problems, because even Biden knows that his own name means nothing but trouble.

Promise Me, America is meant to restore the face of Biden’s foreign policy. Of his first year he writes that he had "restored our alliances," that America once again sat "at the head of the table." Except Joe Biden’s own account of this supposed restoration is not flattering in the slightest to anyone who cares about the Atlantic alliance. Much of it is spent explaining Moscow's feelings.

Early on, Joe Biden introduces Vladimir Putin as a man who once found NATO hard to picture as an enemy, and who phoned George W. Bush before any other world leader following 9/11. But something went wrong. What could it have been? Biden’s first instinct is to blame the West, or more specifically, America. Biden expresses his belief that the reasons that Russia turned against the United States were the Iraq War in 2003 and the expansion of NATO in 2004. Joe Biden’s narrative of early Putin transforms the Russian assault against Ukraine into a reaction to the West’s misdeeds, which allows Biden to portray his appeasement diplomacy as Vice President as a reasonable investment. Biden then recalls NATO’s promise for Ukrainian membership, made at Bucharest in 2008. Biden refers to the promise as “premature,” and allows that Ukraine might end up stuck outside of the NATO alliance merely as a nation with a “special status,” a proposal which he offers as though it were merely a mild observation.

Regarding the slow rationing of weapons to Ukraine following the Russian invasion in 2014, Biden is proud of the pace. As he discusses in Chapter 11, he intentionally withheld aircraft & long-range missiles so that the Russia-Ukraine War would not move “more directly into Russia,” as Biden feared retaliation from Putin.

In each and every case, Biden portrays the Russian grievance, real or manufactured, as a constraint on what NATO and its allies may do, and the cost of that constraint is handed by him to someone else, be it the Baltic states, Georgia, or Ukraine. If Biden had ever been a president who truly believed in NATO, he would have written a different book, one that portrayed the enlargement of NATO as a triumph, and counted the states it protected. The Baltic states joined NATO unanimously in 2004 and have not been invaded since. Georgia and Ukraine were left outside of the alliance and were. Biden does not take any time to acknowledge these fundamental realities.

Nothing here depends on guessing his motives. It depends on his sentences. Where the memoir concedes a premise, we quote it and ask why the conclusion was not drawn. Joe Biden treats the 2004 expansion as a provocation that gave Moscow good reason to resent the West. It then treats the 2008 promise to Ukraine as a mistake, and celebrates the 2023 meeting of the Bucharest Nine in Warsaw as a triumph of solidarity between NATO & Eastern Europe.

At Bucharest in April 2008, Germany and France blocked Membership Action Plans for Ukraine and Georgia, which the United States and several eastern members had hoped for, and the compromise was a declaration that the two would eventually become members. NATO's secretary-general said that wording left no real doubt in that regard. So the alliance issued the promise for membership without a plan for Ukraine to join. And the duration during which Ukraine was never admitted following this 2008 plan were during Biden’s own Vice Presidency, making his supposed support for Ukraine’s membership in NATO utterly incoherent with his inaction for the eight years he was in office under President Obama. He was vice president from 2009 to 2017, and during that entire period (from the horse’s mouth), his goal was to improve relations with Russia, including the 2010 New START treaty and the hope that Dmitry Medvedev would bring about reform in the country.

Russia then annexed Crimea in March 2014.

In Chapter 11, Biden discusses the Ukraine War in the winter of 2022 and 2023, centered around the February 2023 train journey to Kyiv. Biden recalls that the United States supplied Ukraine 31 M1A2 Abrams tanks, 90 Stryker personnel carriers and 109 Bradley fighting vehicles, with European allies adding tanks. He then admits that the aid to Ukraine was “measured,” as he had withheld aircraft and offensive weapons from Ukraine such as long-range missiles that could have taken the war more directly into Russia. In other words, while Russia was attacking Ukraine’s cities, the Biden administration directly intervened to stop Ukraine from attacking Russia’s airfields, depots and launch sites.

By mid-2024, the Institute for the Study of War had calculated that the restrictions shielded roughly 1,750 square kilometers of Russian territory used for military purposes and left Russian aircraft free to hit at least 2,480 Ukrainian settlements without leaving Russian airspace. Only on November 17th to 18th, 2024, after the presidential elections, did the US authorize Ukraine to use donated long-range missiles against targets inside Russia. Putin had warned in June 2022 that sending advanced weapons would lead Russia to strike into the West, and Russia warned in September 2022, that long-range donations would make the United States a party to the conflict. When ATACMS arrived in October 2023, none of the escalations that Moscow had threatened the West with ended up surviving. In other words, Biden’s cowardly restraint had been for nothing. The adversary's threat had merely set the pace of the defender's help.

And still, Biden had no shortage of critiques for his own Ukrainian ‘allies,’ proclaiming:

“We were proud, of course, of our Ukrainian allies. But I must admit that it could be difficult to work with Zelenskyy. As brave as he and the Ukrainians were, they tested our patience on many occasions, demanding more armaments and money. … Zelenskyy could be moody and stubborn in our private conversations, and not as grateful as I would have expected. That could be frustrating, and I let him know that in no uncertain terms.”

This wasn’t even the worst of Biden’s soft-handed restraint. In early 2022, and lasting until March of 2025, the Biden administration established General License 8L, exempting major Russian banks from energy-related sanctions. The explicit goal of this sanctions relief measure was to avoid global energy price spikes. In practice, it allowed Russian banks to facilitate hard-currency payments for Russian energy exports, one of the largest revenue streams supporting the Russian state and war effort. The Biden administration extended it repeatedly.

In Chapter 13, Biden condemns Trump’s tariffs on China in strong terms. It says they were supposed to shrink the deficit and revive manufacturing, that they "predictably" did neither, and it cites one Federal Reserve Bank of New York finding that the trade war cost American companies $1.7 trillion in value. Yet, as has been widely reported, the Biden administration kept most of those tariffs in place and raised duties on Chinese electric vehicles and other strategic goods in 2024.

In Chapter 5, Biden flatly states that Saudi Arabia strained relations by ordering the 2018 murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi. Later, in Chapter 12, he adds that he was outraged by Saudi Arabia’s complicity in his death, and that one of his first presidential acts was to release the intelligence assigning blame to Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. Yet, in July of 2022, he traveled to Jeddah anyway, with a one sentence justification: The relationship between the two countries, Biden writes, was more important than his own relationship with the crown prince. As a candidate in 2019, Joe Biden had vowed to make Saudi Arabia a "pariah" over its human rights record, and his literal fist bump with the crown prince became the defining image of his entire 2022 trip. As critics from the Washington Post to Human Rights Watch remarked, Biden had sold his principle for oil.

Biden describes how by 2023, an economic corridor had emerged between India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor, a rail and ports link running from Mumbai through the Gulf and Israel to southern Europe. Biden proclaimed that this was a new alignment whose center was a relationship between Saudi Arabia and Israel, a relationship he had been working to construct since his visit in 2022. The crown prince, he wrote, said he was ready to move toward ties with Israel, together with bilateral agreements to be assembled in coming months on defense relations, civil nuclear cooperation and technology. A cease-fire in Yemen had been brokered.

"It felt like a new beginning."

In Chapter 15, Biden opens by listing a series of presidents who sided against striking workers, including Rutherford B. Hayes, who sent troops against a railroad strike in 1877, Grover Cleveland doing likewise in 1894, and Ronald Reagan firing more than 11,000 air traffic controllers in 1981. Biden presents himself as the opposite. He recounts how he stood with striking autoworkers at Willow Run in 2023, bullhorn in hand, proceeding to exclaim that no sitting president had ever walked a picket line.

"This is what it means to be a pro-union president."

But is it really? Chapter 15's list of strike-breaking presidents begins with a railroad strike. Biden never mentions the railroad dispute that arose on Biden's own watch. In September 2022, four railroad unions rejected a national agreement. With a strike scheduled for December 9, Biden's administration urged Congress to act, and on December 2 he signed H.J. Res. 100, which imposed the contract on those four unions and banned them from striking. The House passed it 290 to 137 and the Senate 80 to 15. The House also adopted, 221 to 207, an amendment to add paid sick leave, but it failed in the Senate by 52 to 43, short of the 60 votes required. It is quite unfortunate that Biden, in proclaiming his break from the presidents of the robber baron era, merely replicated their failures.

Biden bitterly recalls that the Teamsters declined to back Biden’s 2024 campaign, referring to their refusal as a “finger in the eye,” given that Biden had “saved their pensions.” Likewise, the Longshoremen refused to endorse Biden for president, despite the fact that they had endorsed him four years earlier in 2020. Yet, in Biden’s eyes, both the Teamsters and the Longshoremen were merely being ungrateful for his benevolent deeds. Here we are confronted with, apparently, two Bidens: One Biden, who cheers for the workers while standing at the picket lines with a megaphone, and another Biden, who breaks strikes and expects unconditional approval regardless. To working class Americans, only one of these was the real Biden, and actions speak far louder than words. This Biden is not dissimilar to the same one who seemed displeased by the “moodiness” of a Ukrainian president fighting for the survival of his country.

The common thread of Biden’s presidency was a style of governance that prized the posture of strength, the coalition, the speech, the picket line photo-shoot, and failed to sustain the commitments that make America’s strength credible. Biden’s presidency was one that wanted the credit for restraint and for resolve at the same time, and so he delivered what he believed were a measured amount of each. Whether those measurements fell embarrassingly short is for the American people to decide, but if Promise Me, America is any indication, the results speak for themselves.

The Biden administration did have notable successes, including admitting Finland & Sweden into NATO, and signing legislation that allowed America to produce one of the quickest recoveries from COVID-19 globally. The Biden administration’s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law stands apart as one of the largest infrastructure packages in decades, while the Inflation Reduction Act stands as one of the most important climate and clean-energy investments to date. During the Biden era, millions of jobs were created, unemployment reached near historic lows for an extended period across many demographic groups, and the median household made some real wealth gains as manufacturing construction spending hit records. Even Donald Trump praised Biden’s job creation, claiming it was “extraordinary.” On November 13th, 2024, in a rare bitter-sweet moment of reflection from the president-elect, Trump remarked to Biden “You know, Joe, if it weren’t for politics, I believe we’d be good friends.” When Biden appeared too stunned to speak, Donald continued, “Yes, if it weren’t for politics, we’d spend all our time golfing together.”

This was the same Donald Trump in 2024, who, on January 20th of 2021, had left Biden a letter remarking “Many presidents have come and gone who simply governed as Republicans or Democrats. Largely, they did not change history, they were just swept along in its relentless tide. This will not happen to you because I know how much you love the American people. … May God bless you and Jill, and may God bless America! … Sincerely, Donald” Joe Biden knew that an olive branch of peace was being extended to him, and he chose not to grab it, instead casting Trump supporters as extremists who threatened the foundations of the American Republic.

None of those victories changed the fact that the Biden administration was one of the most chaotic in American history, confusing restraint with resolve, and determination with concession. When Biden is remembered in the succeeding decades and centuries, it will not be for the restoration of America’s alliances, nor for his restraint. It will be for a presidency that repeatedly announced strength, then made every subsequent decision to avoid the costs of enforcing it. The same Biden who celebrated Finland and Sweden’s entry into NATO, supplied Ukraine with its tanks and Bradleys, walked with strikers, vowed to isolate Saudi Arabia, and denounced Trump’s tariffs on China, simultaneously treated NATO’s expansion as a justification for Russian aggression, denied Ukraine aircraft and anti-missile systems, barred workers from striking, signed new agreements with Saudi Arabia, and expanded tariffs on Chinese goods.

Promise Me, America was published to restore a face to the record of Biden’s legacy, because the truth was that the pearly-white Biden smile featured on his inaugural portrait, and the tainted record he left behind were never reconcilable in the slightest.

Next
Next

The Electoral College: The Last Relic of Financial Democracy